Check whether later papers support or dispute a claim
See how a paper has been cited, supporting, contrasting or just mentioning, before relying on its findings.
The use case
A heavily cited paper may be cited mostly by people who failed to replicate it. scite classifies citation statements as supporting, contrasting or mentioning, and its assistant answers questions with references drawn from that citation data. Researchers and students use it to check whether a finding has held up and to find counter-evidence. The researcher still reads the actual citing passages, because automated classification of tone can be wrong, and weighs study quality, not just counts. It is a quick sanity check before building a project or a policy argument on a single result.
Example workflow
- Look up the paper or claim
- Review counts of supporting and contrasting citations
- Read the citing passages
- Follow up on contrasting studies
- Note the balance of evidence in your work
Tools
- scite
Risks and guardrails
- Citation classification can be wrong
- Counts do not reflect study quality
- Coverage depends on publisher access
Sources
Written by Agents Lookup. Credits and official pages for the tools this use case names:
- scite: scite.ai
- Scite (official page): scite.ai/mcp (checked 2026-11-19)