Support conversation quality review sampling
Each week, an agent samples closed support conversations, scores them against the team's written quality checklist, and prepares notes for the support lead to use in coaching conversations.
The use case
Support leads in small teams rarely have time to review conversations for quality, so feedback happens only after a complaint. A written quality checklist exists but is applied unevenly. Each week, the agent samples a set of closed conversations per team member, including some with low satisfaction scores, reopened tickets, or long resolution times. It reviews each one against the checklist, such as correct answer, policy followed, clear next steps, and tone, and writes short notes with quotes from the conversation that support each point. It highlights good examples as well as problems. The support lead reads the notes, checks the conversations, adjusts the scores, and decides what feedback to give. The agent does not score performance for pay or discipline decisions and does not message team members directly.
Example workflow
- Each week, the agent samples closed conversations from Zendesk, Help Scout, or Intercom using rules set by the support lead.
- It includes a mix of random conversations and those with low ratings, reopens, or long resolution times.
- It reviews each conversation against the written quality checklist and notes evidence for each item.
- It drafts notes per team member with strengths and areas to improve, linking each point to the conversation.
- The support lead reviews the notes in Google Docs, adjusts scores, and uses them in one-to-one conversations.
- Common issues across the team are listed so the lead can update saved replies or training.
Tools
- Zendesk
- Help Scout
- Intercom
- Google Docs
- Google Sheets
- Claude
Risks and guardrails
- Scores are used for pay or disciplinary decisions without human review — guardrail: notes are coaching drafts only, and the lead reviews every conversation before using them.
- The agent misjudges tone or context — guardrail: each point links to the conversation so the lead can verify it.
- Sampling misses important problems — guardrail: the lead sets sampling rules and can add specific conversations.
- Team members feel monitored without explanation — guardrail: the checklist and review process are shared openly with the team.
Related recipe
Support Ticket and Review Triage with Policy-Cited Draft Replies: An agent tags every helpdesk ticket and public review by intent, urgency, and sentiment, routes it, and drafts a reply that cites your help center. People approve refunds and all public replies.
Want it set up for you? Request a quote.
Sources
Written by Agents Lookup. Credits and official pages for the tools this use case names:
- Zendesk AI (official page): www.zendesk.com/service/ai (checked 2026-11-09)
- Help Scout (official page): www.helpscout.com (checked 2026-11-09)
- Intercom MCP server (official page): developers.intercom.com/docs/guides/mcp (checked 2026-11-09)
- Claude (official page): claude.ai (checked 2026-11-09)